A mind-boggling "coincidence" leads the filmmaker to track down his fifth grade class – and fifth grade teacher – to examine their memory of and complicity in a bullying incident fifty years ago.
You can now watch When We Were Bullies online on the following streaming providers in the United States.
| Directing | Jay Rosenblatt | Director |
| Writing | Jay Rosenblatt | Writer |
| Production | Jay Rosenblatt | Producer |
| Production | Elena Filippini | Producer |
| Production | Stefano Tealdi | Producer |
| Sound | Erik Ian Walker | Original Music Composer |
| Camera | Paul Foster | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Kirsten Johnson | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Ellie McCutcheon | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Jay Rosenblatt | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Jerome Rosenblatt | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Roberta Rosenblatt | Director of Photography |
| Sound | Pete Horner | Sound |
| Sound | Judy Karp | Sound Recordist |
| Visual Effects | Jeremy Rourke | Animation |
| Editing | Robert Arnold | Colorist |
| Editing | Robert Arnold | Color Grading |
| Editing | Jim Farber | Online Editor |
| Editing | Summers Henderson | Online Editor |
| Sound | Michele Walther | Musician |
| Writing | Ellen Bruno | Script Consultant |
| Writing | Stephanie Rapp | Script Consultant |
| Writing | Caveh Zahedi | Script Consultant |
| Production | Shaleece Haas | Production Consultant |
| Production | Lucas Morrison | Researcher |
