An anthology film consisting of four segments, entitled "Hot Boys," "The Sleep Creep," "The Meat Man," and "Silver Bullets," each of which obliquely dramatizes an incident of sexual assault. The four stories take place in the same small American town on four different holidays: Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Valentine's Day. "What Fun We Were Having" screened publicly once at the 2011 Fantasia International Film Festival, but received no further distribution.
| Crew | Adam Wingard | Cinematography |
| Writing | Adam Wingard | Writer |
| Writing | Simon Barrett | Writer |
| Editing | Adam Wingard | Editor |
| Writing | E.L. Katz | Writer |
| Directing | Adam Wingard | Director |
| Production | Travis Stevens | Producer |
| Art | Jasper Lee | Art Direction |
| Camera | Chris Hilleke | Assistant Camera |
| Production | Joe Swanberg | Producer |
| Production | Travis Stevens | Executive Producer |
| Production | Alex Justinger | Producer |
| Sound | Jasper Lee | Music |