Unexpected Peace follows social anthropologist Jonathan Bornman as he explores three stories: the Amish school shooting in Nickle Mines, PA; the murders of Murid (Sufi Muslim) migrants from Senegal in Harlem, New York; and Muslim-Christian conflict in Solo, Indonesia. In each case, communities responded to horrific acts of violence with forgiveness and actions of nonviolence.
| Directing | D. Michael Hostetler | Director |
| Writing | Jonathan Bornman | Writer |
| Production | Jonathan Bornman | Producer |
| Production | Ehab Assal | Producer |
| Production | D. Michael Hostetler | Producer |
| Writing | D. Michael Hostetler | Writer |
| Camera | Ehab Assal | Director of Photography |
| Editing | Eyas Salman | Editor |
| Sound | Ben Bolt-Martin | Music |